top of page

Verifying CVs: what we found in a cybersecurity search

Nov 3
2 min read

In a recent search for cybersecurity and infrastructure profiles in Mexico's financial sector, 31% of CVs didn't match what we found when we verified them.


What did we find?


  • A management title that, according to the employment letter, was one level lower.

  • A certification presented as current that was actually a short course.

  • Duplicate certification numbers.

  • Fourteen months of overlapping dates.

  • A team of five people that, in the interview, turned out to be three.


Almost all of these were exaggerations: a higher title or a certification that was no longer current. In one case, the overlapping dates were a mistake the candidate corrected. That's why we talk about CVs that don't match, not candidates who lie.


How is it detected?


These gaps rarely come up in a technical interview. They come up when you:


  • ask for the employment letter and compare it with the title on the CV;

  • review the IMSS record (Mexico's social security history): employers, dates and contribution salary;

  • look up each certification number on the issuer's website;

  • check the professional license (cédula profesional) in Mexico's National Registry of Professionals.


What do studies say?


The Mexican study closest to what we did is MultiLatin Background Screening's (2019). It verified 42,000 candidates and found inconsistencies in the work history of 22% and in the academic history of 10%. The same study reports that only 28% of companies in Mexico verify CVs, and that the interview detects false information in 35% of cases.


Academic research explains why it matters. Henle, Dineen and Duffy (Journal of Business and Psychology, 2019) distinguish three types of CV deception: fabricating, embellishing and omitting. They found that CV fraud predicts lower performance and more problematic behavior at work.


Figures vary widely depending on how they're measured. Surveys where candidates admit to "presenting themselves differently" reach 78% (Checkster, 2020), because they include even exaggerating a skill. Anonymous techniques bring it down to 5% (Dectech, 2019). Our figure is measured against documents and falls within the range of the comparable Mexican study.


What it means for employers


Several of those candidates were good and stayed in the process. Verifying isn't about ruling people out; it's about making sure whoever decides knows what they're working with before making an offer.


Hiring? Tell us what profile you need.


Angel Rossio Millán

IT Headhunter | Master's in Human Resources Management, EAE Business School Barcelona


Sources

 
 
bottom of page